—
Source: WXYZ
Summary
The Western Michigan and Michigan game ended with a controversial Hail Mary touchdown by Bryce Underwood, leading to disputes over the game clock. The Big Ten confirmed the call stood, and the MAC appealed but was denied by the NCAA. Both teams moved on to Week 2, with the outcome remaining a point of contention. Michigan won 13-12, and the play became a major talking point in college football.
Our Reading
This one felt recognizable early.
Western Michigan led late, then fell apart.
Underwood launched two Hail Marys, one with a second left.
Officials used TV footage, not their own, to make the call.
The MAC appealed, but the NCAA said no changes. Fans still wonder what if.
Author: Evan Null
Controversy Over the Final Play
The ending of the Western Michigan and Michigan game sparked immediate controversy. The final play saw Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood throw a Hail Mary that was initially ruled incomplete. However, after a review, officials determined that one second remained on the clock, allowing Underwood to throw a second Hail Mary that resulted in a touchdown. The decision left fans and analysts divided, with questions about the accuracy of the clock and the replay process.
Timeline of Events
The game began with Michigan as a heavy favorite, but Western Michigan kept the game close. At one point, the Broncos led 12-6. The game seemed to be over when Underwood’s first Hail Mary was ruled incomplete. However, after a review, officials determined that one second remained, leading to a second attempt. The final play was a touchdown, giving Michigan a 13-12 win. The decision was controversial and led to widespread discussion across college football.
Reactions from Coaches and Officials
Michigan coach Kyle Whittingham acknowledged the close call but supported the officials’ decision. Western Michigan coach Lance Taylor admitted his defense failed to execute on the second play. Both coaches avoided making excuses, though Taylor expressed concerns about the timing of the play. The Big Ten and MAC both issued statements, with the Big Ten confirming the call stood and the MAC appealing the decision.
Media and Analysts Weigh In
Media outlets like NBC Sports and FOX Sports covered the controversy extensively. Host John Fanta reminded viewers that TV graphics do not dictate official game time. Analyst Mike Pereira explained that officials used TV footage to make the call, which led to criticism. Pereira defended the officials but criticized the outcome, stating that the replay process did not follow protocol.
Appeals and Final Outcome
The MAC initially accepted the ruling but later appealed, claiming that replay protocol was not followed. However, the NCAA denied the appeal, stating that it could not alter the final score of the game. With the outcome confirmed, both teams moved on to Week 2, but the game will be remembered as a “what-if” moment for fans of Western Michigan. The controversy surrounding the final play will likely continue to be discussed in college football circles.
