Source: Fox News
Summary
Utah Supreme Court Justice Diana Hagen has resigned amid a probe into an alleged relationship with an attorney, David Reymann, who worked on a redistricting lawsuit. Hagen denied the allegations and had recused herself from cases involving Reymann in May 2025. In her resignation letter, she stated that she could not continue serving on the bench without sacrificing the privacy and well-being of her loved ones and the independence of Utah’s judiciary.
Our Reading
As expected, the matter has reached another stage.
Justice Diana Hagen’s resignation comes after a probe into her alleged relationship with an attorney who worked on a redistricting lawsuit. The investigation was sparked by a complaint from Hagen’s former husband, who accused her of sending “inappropriate” text messages to the attorney. The Judicial Conduct Commission conducted a preliminary investigation but chose not to pursue the matter further. Hagen had recused herself from cases involving the attorney in May 2025. The resignation was effective immediately, and Utah Gov. Spencer Cox will name her replacement.
The process of investigating and addressing allegations against public officials has entered a familiar phase.
The investigation and resignation have followed a predictable pattern, with the accused official denying the allegations and eventually resigning to protect their loved ones and the institution they serve.
It’s a reminder that public officials are held to a higher standard, and their personal lives are subject to public scrutiny.
The resignation highlights the challenges of maintaining privacy and independence in public life.
One observation: The timing of Hagen’s resignation, effective immediately, suggests that the investigation had reached a point where her continued service on the bench was no longer tenable.
Author: Evan Null
